Football Message Board

Joined: 11/27/2003 Posts: 34640
Likes: 12332

What's this?

There's a problem with splitting revenue evenly among schools

If each school gets $10 million to pay players, that's a disadvantage for schools in high cost areas. How much will that matter when recruiting?? I don't know. You can bet Nick Saban would tell a recruit "Hey, we'll pay you the same as USC and the money will go twice as far in Tuscaloosa". (I know I'm crossing conferences but you get the point)

OTOH if the money is divided with cost of living in mind, that would also be used when recruiting because schools in high cost areas can simply pay more than other schools for players.

I don't see how this can be done equitably. I think the NCAA knew what they were doing by keeping money out of the equation.

(In response to this post by HallelujahBuff)

Posted: 05/10/2022 at 7:27PM

PREV NEXT REPLY

Insert a Link

Enter the title of the link here:

Enter the full web address of the link here -- include the "http://" part:

Current Thread:

NIL will not be the end game or the solution -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 12:20PM

I don't see how universities will pay a "fair" salary -- CUKev 05/10/2022 4:59PM

Salary cap ** -- hawg1 05/10/2022 5:39PM

NFL gets antitrust exemption for salary cap because is in union contract. -- 2011 05/11/2022 4:12PM

Can you explain what you mean?? -- CUKev 05/10/2022 5:42PM

It’s a possible answer to the conundrum you posed in your last paragraph ** -- hawg1 05/10/2022 5:44PM

Make em employees. Tax everything, including scholarships -- Colo Spgs Buff 05/10/2022 1:31PM

Wait, they are being taxed, right? -- JeffGerardi 05/11/2022 07:17AM

I agree ... they should be taxed -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 1:37PM

Love it ** -- Colo Spgs Buff 05/10/2022 1:57PM

The tax argument is one of the worst ones out there -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 2:08PM

I am not sure I understand what you are saying. Why should their -- Colo Spgs Buff 05/10/2022 2:24PM

Yeah, like slaves were compensated -- EBN 05/10/2022 2:43PM

Yeah, i don't see it that way at all. just seems like there is -- Colo Spgs Buff 05/10/2022 9:23PM

Perhaps, but not on the backs of the kids ** -- EBN 05/11/2022 07:28AM

College football players are treated like slaves?????????? -- CUKev 05/10/2022 5:22PM

They work their asses off to make money for their masters ** -- EBN 05/10/2022 5:45PM

Really dumb comment -- BadgerBuff 05/10/2022 11:02PM

Know what I'm tired of hearing? -- EBN 05/11/2022 07:26AM

No offense taken -- BadgerBuff 05/11/2022 2:03PM

You have a subjective point of view, obviously. -- Colo Spgs Buff 05/11/2022 12:58PM

Yes, they do work hard -- CUKev 05/10/2022 7:13PM

They can leave at any time. Slaves didn't have a transfer portal to a -- The Midnight Toker 05/10/2022 6:23PM

I think the tax issue is being blown out of proportion -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 2:55PM

An argument can be made for taxing NIL money, that's income -- EBN 05/10/2022 3:19PM

Opens up all scholarships to all students being taxed. Not happening. ** -- hawg1 05/10/2022 3:26PM

What value do NARPs bring to the University? -- EBN 05/10/2022 3:38PM

Can I assume you -- BadgerBuff 05/10/2022 11:21PM

His daughter runs XC at Vandy. He knows the landscape. ** -- hawg1 05/11/2022 10:29AM

Pretty sure I know something about it. ** -- EBN 05/11/2022 07:27AM

Congrats on your dad in XC. Track coach here but -- BadgerBuff 05/11/2022 1:54PM

Re: I am not sure I understand what you are saying. Why should their -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 2:33PM

Isn’t the free education and room & board compensation? -- IdaBuff 05/10/2022 12:53PM

This used to be a valid argument. Now we have stipends, COA allowances and -- hawg1 05/10/2022 1:14PM

It is definitely not "fair market" compensation -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 1:04PM

No, I would not trade my compensation -- CUKev 05/10/2022 5:28PM

Can you throw a football 60 yards, or run a 4.35 40? -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 5:59PM

I understand what you're saying -- CUKev 05/10/2022 7:18PM

Given the flex in the limit of enrollment the scholarship could -- Go2Bowl 05/10/2022 1:30PM

You are 100% correct ... it's an accounting gimick -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 1:46PM

Incorrect -- TBonePickens 05/10/2022 6:34PM

Thank you for that information -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 6:53PM

I’m not interested in limiting their compensation -- IdaBuff 05/10/2022 1:30PM

If they didn’t like the old system -- Irish Buff 05/10/2022 1:24PM

Re: If they didn’t like the old system -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 2:18PM

You are comparing a DOCTOR -- Irish Buff 05/10/2022 7:16PM

Every player has different value -- CUKev 05/10/2022 5:05PM

I never said I would pay them the same amounts -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 5:46PM

There's a problem with splitting revenue evenly among schools -- CUKev 05/10/2022 7:27PM

Hoarse voices screaming at a battalion of jackhammers. -- hawg1 05/10/2022 2:20PM

Taxing scholarships, including those of non-SAs, is a bad idea IMO. -- hawg1 05/10/2022 1:39PM

Yup ** -- Colo Spgs Buff 05/10/2022 1:35PM

Further more -- Irish Buff 05/10/2022 1:51PM

They already do ... its called the portal -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 1:59PM

Where can I get reliable information -- Irish Buff 05/10/2022 7:17PM

Adam Munstertiger talked about it on a recent podcast -- HallelujahBuff 05/10/2022 7:23PM

Make 'em stand outside the UMC and stone 'em all ** -- EBN 05/10/2022 1:58PM

Now ur on to something 😂😂😂🦬 ** -- Irish Buff 05/10/2022 7:18PM

I know of people getting “stoned” in college ** -- IdaBuff 05/10/2022 3:33PM

Had to chuckle at that one ** -- Go2Bowl 05/10/2022 2:45PM

Get off my lawn. ** -- hawg1 05/10/2022 2:00PM

You are arguing for unions in CFB in your last two posts ** -- hawg1 05/10/2022 1:56PM

Right -- Irish Buff 05/10/2022 7:20PM